Site Meter Worldly Chatter » Blog Archive » Cultural Identity, who can judge?

Cultural Identity, who can judge?

by Samantha Schmalfuss

Part one of this found here.

I wrote about Princess Maxima and her comment about the Dutch people not having an identity the other day. I wrote about how the Dutch people feel she isn’t Dutch enough to understand the populous, either individually or as a whole. Because she is from Argentina and only a Dutch national for 6 years they feel she doesn’t get them. They have an identity, individualistic and collectively.

So I tossed Dutchie a thought. When I was still living in America, Dutchie and I got into some heated debates about America and the American population. She gave me her opinion on the government and the people as she saw them there in the US and abroad. I saw the country and its people one way ad she saw some completely different things. How can this be? She saw American news as bias and misguided. I knew that the news on particular channels was favored one way or the other but what do you mean misguided? According to her, we didn’t everything she did. Preposterous and around we would go for another round of debates! When I arrived I finally understood. The news was different; the way Americans are perceived here is different from how we see ourselves. But how was I going to know that unless I stepped outside my one limited line of sight? One must really step outside the bubble to see everything that is inside it. If it is too crowded where you stand how are you going to see what is on the other side?

With that said, when I landed here in this little country I had a loud smack of a culture shock and a wakeup call when it came to my own country and previous way of living. What I saw about my own country from their eyes was astonishing. The way they saw our personalities, our policies and government was strong, sometimes good and sometimes bad but definitely had a thought on it all. The continent of Europe deals with America on many levels. Our American culture floods over theirs in the movies, television and other forms of media and entertainment. It is hard to move away from another country when it is all around you. What the government does what the celebrities do and what America creates spills over here. It is the same way on the other side. Business, fashion, government policies etc but not everyone sees it, or cares to. You would have an opinion about such a force too.

If Dutchie steps up to me with her thoughts on my country and all that that means then why can’t someone coming into their country? We now talk a great deal about my experiences here, my thoughts on how I see things and we don’t always agree. I may see something one way and she gets insulted or upset because it is different from what she sees. It is the same thing as when I was living in America. Did that make her think? I am outside her Dutch bubble just as she was outside my American bubble. Maybe the Princess was just trying to say that the Dutch person is an individual and that there is not one personality type that dominates the Dutch population, that they are truly all different and in that respect, isn’t that a compliment? They aren’t mindless drones but rather individuals in their own right. Again, why didn’t the Princess just say that? I haven’t a clue but maybe that is what she was trying to say. One really only knows but like I mentioned earlier the prime minister was trying to straighten it all out. It wasn’t meant to be taken that way. The Princess is in the same position I am and Dutchie is when she goes to America. What do you think? Was she wrong for speaking about the people when she wasn’t one herself or was she simply making an observation about what she sees as an outsider looking in?

, , ,


Leave a Reply


About Worldly Chatter

These are the thoughts and expressions in everyday life and travel of an American after trading in her homeland for a new and exciting place in Europe. The differences in culture, politics and global events as construed by the author; bringing the wonder and clarity of both America and Europe through a unique perspective of traveler finally awakened, with hints and tips for the migrant, or immigrant bohemian desiring to explore the center of their own beginnings.

Worldly Chatter Author(s)

http://rpc.technorati.com/rpc/ping

Travel Channel Posts

  • Festival surprise
    [...]
  • All about Perth
      I headed from Melbourne over to Perth, which surprisingly is often missed by travellers and holiday makers but I love the place! There are fabulous beaches and the water in the Indian Ocean is [...]
  • What? A holiday in England!
      (Photo from www.freefoto.com) I’m from England and have travelled there a fair bit but generally if I want a holiday I head straight to somewhere else in Europe as I always thought that [...]
  • Out with a Tuk-tuk driver
      I was in Bangkok and I wanted somewhere to go that I hadn’t been before. Anyway, I got chatting to one of the tuk-tuk drivers and his English was excellent and he told me about loads of [...]
  • Earthcore Festival
      Earthcore festival happens in two states in Australia every year and has been going for over ten years and takes place in two locations; New South Wales and Victoria. The only festival I had [...]
  • A day on the Ocean
      As I was travelling around Malaysia I discovered the beauty of Langkawi. The island itself is huge but there isn’t a great deal going on. On land there are a few waterfalls, and amazing white [...]
  • Mad about Meat!
    If you are vegetarian and thinking about going to The Philippines, please, think again! I was warned about it before I went but like usual I took no notice and thought that it wouldn’t be as [...]
  • The Great Ocean Road
      ( The 12 Apostles, photo by Robert S Butler) The Great Ocean Road stretches along the coast not to far from Australia’s well loved Melbourne and it’s a great place for adventure, [...]
  • Off to the Pyramids
      (Photo taken by Trevor Lowe) I remember going to Egypt to see the pyramids in Giza a few years back. I was really excited to be there even though I was melting due to the heat, and it [...]
  • Christmas in Paris
      (Photo by Eric Rougier www.fromparis.com) Personally I hate Christmas, I always have and I always will and I will do whatever I can to get away from it! So I decided to take my mum to Paris [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Brennan and Jared: what did you think?
    When they first said that there was going to be a Bones/younger-brother Booth romance I was really disappointed. Then, when they reasoned that it was going to, in the long run, bring Bones and [...]
  • Quotes of the Week...
    This episode had lots of good ones. Let's not waste time shall we? Here are my favorites... Carlos: Did I ever tell you when I knew I was going to marry you? Gaby: When you saw me on the [...]
  • Javier Vazquez on The Move...
    Javier Vazquez is on the move, and is likely headed from the Chicago White Sox to the Atlanta Braves in a huge trade. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported the White Sox would also send [...]
  • Pedroia Signs Extension With Red Sox...
    AL MVP Dustin Pedroia today signed a six-year, $40.5 million extension with Boston through 2014 with a club option for the 2015 season. According to ESPN, the second baseman will receive a $1.5 [...]
  • Photos of Ted Dibiase ON-SET of "Marine 2", Matt Hardy "Singles", Trained by Funk and More
    -As reported earlier here, Ted Dibiase has been written out of the WWE storyline. Dibiase has been acting in WWE's newest movie "The Marine 2". More photos of Ted Dibiase on the set of Marine 2, Go [...]
  • Study Says One Fifth of Young Americans Have Personality Disorders
    Did they really need to do a study on how many college-age Americans have personailty disorders? I think we already knew the results to this one. According to a study funded by the National [...]
  • WWE Diva Brie Bella: Piñata Princess - Photos
    [gallery] Here is your ONE HALF of The Bella Twins..your Piñata Princess, Brie Bella....ENJOY!!! [...]
  • Kids TV on DVD: Rugrats Holiday Celebration
    Rugrats Holiday Celebration is a two disc set of holiday themed Rugrats episodes. The first disc has five Halloween themed episodes. Since I am focusing on Christmas/winter episodes for Tots TV [...]
  • Soap Opera Ratings From Last Week
    Here are last week's soap opera ratings The Young and the Restless 3.20 The Bold and the Beautiful 2.40 General Hospital 2.00 Days of Our Lives 1.90 One [...]
  • Circus Review - pt 3!
    Hey ya'll! Since I can do the snarky comments without thinking, and post pictures galore, I thought it'd be nice for you all to hear a review from someone who simply 'gets' music - unlike my "yeah, I [...]